Taxonomy of Reviews

I believe that Campbell's taxonomy of reviews is more efficient and useful. I like how you can see that each review is a step after the next. When I review a document, there are different things I look for each time, which is why a list of steps to follow is very useful. Campbell’s simplifies and labels the steps that I already follow when reviewing a document. Barker's list of reviews may be useful for those who work with different types of documents that need to be reviewed by multiple people, but I still believe that Campbell's may still be more useful since it is generalized to fit any type of document.